[Scubacat]

I have a MIO C520 that I have been VERY happy with. I love how much info it gives on the home screen, how customizable it is and how sharp and easy to read the maps are. It, however, is beginning to act up and the battery is at the end of it's life. I would find another one but to get one with the same map is mine means they are 4 years old and I have been told the update changed alot of how it looks and works.

My wife has a Garmin NUVI. I HATE this device with a fiery passion. It is not intuitive, it gives little data other than the core directions, it, IMO, gives worse directions than my MIO, and has maps that look like a dim witted 6 year old with crayons drew.

My father has a TOMTOM, I have not used it enough to get a good feel for it. It's maps seems marginally better drawn than the Garmin.

I have no hands on experience with Magellen but they always seem to rank near the bottom in what I have read.

Based on all of that, what would you suggest as my next device?